Timothy G. NeCastro

President and Chief Executive Officer · Erie Insurance Group

Property, Casualty and Life Insurance

Timothy G. NeCastro is president and chief executive officer of Erie Insurance Group. He built his career across accounting, product services and regional sales operations before becoming CEO in 2016. His announced retirement is effective December 31, 2026.

Last reviewed: Oct 21, 2026

Timothy G. NeCastro

President and Chief Executive Officer Erie Insurance Group

Last Reviewed: October 21, 2026

Executive Summary

Timothy G. NeCastro is president and chief executive officer of Erie Insurance Group. He built his career across accounting, product services and regional sales operations before becoming CEO in 2016. His announced retirement is effective December 31, 2026.

Career Highlights

  • Became CEO in August 2016 after leading the company’s western region.
  • Led ERIE’s 2014 expansion into Kentucky, its twelfth state.
  • Founded the board of the Erie Downtown Development Corporation and chairs Infinite Erie.

Professional Journey

NeCastro began in public accounting, spending ten years at Ernst & Young and advancing to senior manager. He subsequently worked as director of finance at The Plastek Group before joining ERIE in 1996 to manage internal auditing.

He became senior vice president of the Controller Division in 1997. In 2008, he moved into operations as senior vice president of Product and Policy Services. His 2010 appointment as senior vice president and regional officer extended his experience into field sales across several Midwestern and Appalachian states. He later led the company’s entry into Kentucky.

NeCastro became CEO in August 2016 and added the president title in January 2017, according to the company’s contemporaneous SEC chronology. His tenure included ERIE’s 2025 centennial. In February 2026, the company announced that he would retire as president and CEO on December 31, remaining in office through the transition. It said he would subsequently serve as president of the Erie Insurance Foundation.

His civic work includes serving as founding board president of the Erie Downtown Development Corporation, board president of the Mazzini Charitable Foundation and board chair of Infinite Erie. Those roles connect his corporate career with downtown redevelopment and charitable initiatives.

Education

NeCastro earned a bachelor’s degree in accounting from Gannon University. He attended Cathedral Preparatory School before university.