Craig R. Smiddy
President and Chief Executive OfficerOld Republic International
InsuranceView Profile →President & CEO, Columbus Life Insurance Company and The Lafayette Life Insurance Company · Western & Southern Financial Group
John H. Bultema leads Columbus Life Insurance Company and The Lafayette Life Insurance Company as president and CEO within Western & Southern Financial Group. He joined the group in 2017 after a banking career and has led the two insurance subsidiaries since 2019 and 2020, respectively.
Last reviewed: Oct 30, 2026
President & CEO, Columbus Life Insurance Company and The Lafayette Life Insurance Company
Western & Southern Financial Group
Last Reviewed: October 30, 2026
John H. Bultema leads Columbus Life Insurance Company and The Lafayette Life Insurance Company as president and CEO within Western & Southern Financial Group. He joined the group in 2017 after a banking career and has led the two insurance subsidiaries since 2019 and 2020, respectively.
Bultema spent twenty-two years at Fifth Third Bank and Old Kent Bank before joining Western & Southern in 2017 as senior vice president of institutional markets. The appointment moved his career from banking into the diversified insurance and financial services group.
He became president and chief executive officer of The Lafayette Life Insurance Company in 2019. In 2020, he also took the president and CEO position at Columbus Life Insurance Company. His work across the two subsidiaries includes helping shape the enterprise strategy for independent agent distribution.
His community and educational service includes chairing the Best Point board and serving the Grand Valley State University Foundation. He also participates in the University of Cincinnati Lindner School of Business’s Business Advisory Council, alongside his insurance company leadership.
Bultema earned a bachelor’s degree from Grand Valley State University and an MBA from Western Michigan University.