Carl H. Lindner III

Co-Chief Executive Officer and Director · American Financial Group

Property and Casualty Insurance

Carl H. Lindner III is Co-Chief Executive Officer and a director of American Financial Group, with long-standing responsibility for its property and casualty insurance operations.

Last reviewed: Nov 4, 2026

Carl H. Lindner III

Co-Chief Executive Officer and Director
American Financial Group

Last Reviewed: November 4, 2026

Executive Summary

Carl H. Lindner III is Co-Chief Executive Officer and a director of American Financial Group, with long-standing responsibility for its property and casualty insurance operations.

Career Highlights

  • Became AFG’s Co-Chief Executive Officer in January 2005.
  • Has led property and casualty insurance operations since 1987.
  • Co-founded FC Cincinnati and serves as its CEO and controlling owner.

Professional Journey

Lindner gained early operating experience while attending the University of Cincinnati, working part time in family-company assignments that included repossessions, vault cash counting and automobile-loan underwriting. He entered Great American’s property and casualty insurance business in 1975 and progressed through roles of increasing responsibility.

He became principally responsible for the property and casualty operations in 1987. He joined American Financial Group’s board in March 1996 and served as Co-President from 1996 through June 2023. In January 2005, he and his brother S. Craig Lindner became Co-Chief Executive Officers, a role he continues to hold.

His insurance work included shifting the property and casualty portfolio toward specialized markets. The business added operations in areas including environmental insurance, public sector risks, professional liability, aviation and mergers and acquisitions liability.

Outside insurance, Lindner co-founded FC Cincinnati with Jeff Berding in 2015. The club began United Soccer League play in 2016 and joined Major League Soccer in 2019. Lindner remains its Chief Executive Officer and controlling owner.

His educational philanthropy includes helping establish Cincinnati Hills Christian Academy, the Otto Armleder Memorial Education Center and the Carl H. Lindner III Center for Insurance and Risk Management at UC. He served on the university’s board of trustees from 2013 to 2015.

Education

Lindner earned a bachelor’s degree in Business Administration from the University of Cincinnati in 1975, with university profiles identifying his field as Finance.