W. Todd Gray

Executive Vice President and Treasurer · Old Republic International

Insurance

W. Todd Gray is executive vice president and treasurer of Old Republic International. His insurance career spans public accounting, underwriting-company finance, specialty lending and operating-business oversight.

Last reviewed: Nov 2, 2026

W. Todd Gray

Executive Vice President and Treasurer
Old Republic International

Last Reviewed: November 2, 2026

Executive Summary

W. Todd Gray is executive vice president and treasurer of Old Republic International. His insurance career spans public accounting, underwriting-company finance, specialty lending and operating-business oversight.

Career Highlights

  • Started in public accounting at Deloitte before joining The Midland Company in 1994.
  • Served as American Modern’s chief financial officer and later president, and as CFO of Oak Street Funding.
  • Became Old Republic’s treasurer in June 2018 and executive vice president in May 2022.

Professional Journey

Gray started his career at Deloitte before moving to The Midland Company, the publicly traded parent of American Modern Insurance Group, in 1994. He worked as internal audit manager and assistant treasurer before becoming treasurer in 1997. Midland promoted him to executive vice president and chief financial officer on July 27, 2006.

At American Modern, Gray served as chief financial officer and subsequently president. He later became chief financial officer of Oak Street Funding, a commercial lender serving insurance businesses. In 2013, he represented Oak Street in announcing a referral-partner program designed to connect insurance professionals with financing.

Gray joined Old Republic in 2015 as senior vice president of operations and finance for its general insurance group. He added the parent corporation’s senior vice president and treasurer offices on June 1, 2018, while retaining his operating-group responsibilities. He became executive vice president in May 2022.

His responsibilities include treasury operations and direct oversight of Old Republic Asset Management, where he is president. He also oversees the home service contract and auto warranty businesses.

Education

Gray earned a Bachelor of Science in accounting from Indiana University and is a certified public accountant.