Michelle A. Gillis

Senior Vice President, Chief Human Resources Officer and Chief Administrative Officer · American Financial Group

Property and Casualty Insurance

Michelle A. Gillis is Senior Vice President, Chief Human Resources Officer and Chief Administrative Officer of American Financial Group. Her career includes human resources leadership at Fifth Third Bank and Great American Insurance Company.

Last reviewed: Nov 4, 2026

Michelle A. Gillis

Senior Vice President, Chief Human Resources Officer and Chief Administrative Officer
American Financial Group

Last Reviewed: November 4, 2026

Executive Summary

Michelle A. Gillis is Senior Vice President, Chief Human Resources Officer and Chief Administrative Officer of American Financial Group. Her career includes human resources leadership at Fifth Third Bank and Great American Insurance Company.

Career Highlights

  • Joined Great American Insurance Company in 2004.
  • Became Chief Administrative Officer in 2012 and Chief Human Resources Officer in 2022.
  • Serves as Secretary of the University of Cincinnati Board of Trustees.

Professional Journey

Before joining Great American Insurance Company in 2004, Gillis held senior human resources positions at Fifth Third Bank, including Vice President and Senior HR Business Partner. At Great American, she progressed through senior human resources management assignments and became Vice President overseeing Human Resources.

In March 2012, she became Vice President and Chief Administrative Officer of American Financial Group. Her responsibilities covered Human Resources, Corporate Communications, Real Estate and shared service functions. She was elected Senior Vice President in March 2013; AFG announced that promotion the following month. The company added Chief Human Resources Officer to her titles in 2022.

Her administrative work also encompasses Communications, Marketing and Branding and corporate shared services, according to her University of Cincinnati trustee biography.

Gillis serves as Secretary of the University of Cincinnati Board of Trustees. Her other service includes the Cincinnati USA Regional Chamber board, its foundation trustees, the university’s Carl H. Lindner III Center for Insurance and Risk Management advisory board and the UC Health board’s Compensation Committee. She has mentored children at Oyler Elementary through a Cincinnati literacy program. Earlier service included the Seton High School trustees, the Cincinnati YWCA Human Resources Committee and the Camp Joy board.

Education

Gillis earned a Bachelor of Arts in Communication and a Master of Arts in Labor and Employment Relations from the University of Cincinnati. She holds the Senior Professional in Human Resources designation.