Brian S. Hertzman

Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer · American Financial Group

Property and Casualty Insurance

Brian S. Hertzman is Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of American Financial Group. He joined the company in 1991 and advanced through accounting, controller and interim financial officer responsibilities.

Last reviewed: Nov 4, 2026

Brian S. Hertzman

Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer
American Financial Group

Last Reviewed: November 4, 2026

Executive Summary

Brian S. Hertzman is Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of American Financial Group. He joined the company in 1991 and advanced through accounting, controller and interim financial officer responsibilities.

Career Highlights

  • Joined American Financial Group in 1991.
  • Became Controller in 2012 and Vice President in 2014.
  • Elected Chief Financial Officer on August 27, 2020.

Professional Journey

Hertzman joined American Financial Group in 1991 and progressed through its finance and accounting organization. He became Controller in 2012 and Vice President in 2014. In those positions, he oversaw accounting policies and procedures, compliance with generally accepted accounting principles and other applicable regulations, and financial reporting to the Securities and Exchange Commission.

On June 23, 2020, he assumed interim principal financial officer and principal accounting officer responsibilities. The board elected him Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer on August 27, 2020; the company announced the promotion on August 31.

His professional affiliations include the American Institute of CPAs, the Ohio Society of CPAs and Financial Executives International.

Outside AFG, Hertzman has served on the board of Camp Livingston. The Jewish Federation of Cincinnati also lists him on its Board of Trustees as the representative of Camp Livingston.

Education

Hertzman earned a bachelor’s degree in Accounting and Finance from the University of Cincinnati and an MBA in Finance from Xavier University. His Ohio CPA license is inactive.